Monel 400 nyob rau hauv Hydrofluoric Acid: Corrosion Rate ntawm Ntau Qhov Chaw thiab Kub

Sep 24, 2026

Tso lus

Monel 400(UNS N04400, 67% nickel-31.5% tooj liab-1.2% hlau) yog ib qho ntawm ob peb yam hlau uas muaj peev xwm tuav tau hydrofluoric acid (HF) thoob plaws nws cov concentration ntau. Tab sis "yuav daws tau nws" tsis zoo ib yam li "corrodes ntawm pes tsawg tus nqi."

 

Monel 400 in Hydrofluoric Acid

 

Phau ntawv qhia no nthuav tawm cov ntaub ntawv tshaj tawm corrosion- tus nqi cov ntaub ntawv rau Monel 400 hauv HF, qhia meej npaum li cas cov concentration, kub, thiab yaj cov pa oxygen hloov tus nqi, thiab piv Monel 400 tawm tsam Hastelloy C-276, Inconel 600, thiab 316 stainless hlau yog li cov engineers tuaj yeem xaiv cov khoom siv nrog cov lej, tsis suav nrog.

Puas Monel 400 Resistant Hydrofluoric Acid ntawm Txhua Qhov Kev Ntsuas thiab Kub?

Yog lawm, tab sis tsuas yog nyob rau hauv deaerated (oxygen -dawb), kua- theem tej yam kev mob. Nyob rau hauv lub xeev ntawd, Monel 400 resists tseem ceeb txhua HF concentration - los ntawm dilute mus rau ntau tshaj 90% - mus txog rau lub boiling point, nrog ib tug corrosion tus nqi feem ntau qis dua 0.025 mm / xyoo (kwv yees li 1 mil ib xyoos, los yog "mpy").

 

Hydrofluoric acid yog qhov txawv txav: feem ntau cov kua qaub tau nruj dua li cov concentration nce, tab sis HF qhov kev tawm tsam ntawm Monel 400 nyob deb ntau dua ntawm cov ntsiab lus oxygen thiab qhov kub thiab txias dua li qhov concentration ib leeg. Monel cov ntsiab lus tooj liab tsim ib daim nyias nyias, adherent fluoride zaj duab xis ntawm cov hlau nto uas thaiv kev tawm tsam ntxiv, yog tias cov kua qaub tsis yog aerated thiab tsis kis nrog oxidizing ntsev.

 

Thaum cov pa oxygen, huab cua, lossis oxidizing hlau ions (Fe3+, Cu2+) nkag mus rau hauv lub cev, cov yeeb yaj kiab tiv thaiv ntawd tawg thiab tus nqi corrosion tuaj yeem dhia los ntawm ib mus rau ob qhov kev txiav txim loj. Qhov tseeb ib leeg no - oxygen raug teeb meem ntau dua li cov kua qaub zog - yog lub tswv yim tseem ceeb tshaj plaws nyob rau hauv tag nrho cov kab lus no thiab tau piav qhia hauv cov lus hauv qab no.

Qhov Ntsuas Corrosion Rate ntawm Monel 400 hauv Hydrofluoric Acid yog dab tsi?

Kev ywj pheej luam tawm cov ntaub ntawv ntsuam xyuas qhov chaw Monel 400 tus nqi corrosion hauv cov kua HF ntawm li 0.03 thiab 0.04 mm / xyoo (1.2–1.6 mpy) nyob ze ntawm chav tsev kub, nce mus txog 0.25–0.75 mm / xyoo (10–30 mpy) hauv aerated, ambient {{9} thiab qhov kub thiab txias 90-120 degree.

 

Corrosion Rate of Monel 400 in Hydrofluoric Acid

 

Cov lus hauv qab no suav nrog kev txhim kho corrosion- tus nqi ntsuas los ntawm cov phooj ywg- tshuaj xyuas thiab lub teb chaws - qhov chaw kuaj. Cov nqi raug muab hauv millimeters ib xyoos (mm / y) thiab mils ib xyoos (mpy, qhov twg 1 mpy=0.0254 mm / y) yog li cov ntaub ntawv tuaj yeem muab piv ncaj qha rau ASTM / NACE corrosion- pawg hnyav (feem ntau:<0.1 mm/y = excellent/mild; 0.1–0.5 mm/y = acceptable for many services; >0.5 mm / y=feem ntau tsis tuaj yeem lees txais rau lub sijhawm ntev - cov cuab yeej zoo li qub).

 

HF Concentration

Kub

Qhov xwm txheej

Corrosion tus nqi (mm / y)

Corrosion tus nqi (mpy)

Qhov chaw

~4% (1 M)

25 degree

Ua kua, kuaj electrochemical (Tafel)

0.031

1.2

Stathopoulos et al., 2026

40% w/v

25 degree

Kua, huab hwm coj- poob

0.04

1.6

Stathopoulos et al., 2026

33 wt%

~ 23℃(ambient, aerated)

Kev haus dej haus cawv, lub lim tiam 1

< 0.25

< 10

ORNL/TM-2002/165

33 wt%

~ 23℃(ambient, aerated)

Kua immersion, lub lim tiam 4 (tus nqi tseem nce)

≈ 0.74

≈ 29

ORNL/TM-2002/165

49%

88-120℃(kuj)

Vapor, aerated los yog unaerated

Tus nqi pib nrawm nce saum toj no

Tus nqi pib nrawm nce saum toj no

Kane et al., 1993

HF vapor (ntsuas)

200℃(extrapolated)

Vapor

≈ 10 × siab dua Hastelloy C-276 ntawm tib lub sijhawm

≈ 10 × siab dua Hastelloy C-276 ntawm tib lub sijhawm

Rebak et al., 2001

Table 1. Corrosion rate of Monel 400 (alloy 400) nyob rau hauv hydrofluoric acid raws li qhia nyob rau hauv kev soj ntsuam thiab teb cov kev tshawb fawb. 1 mpy=0.0254 mm/y.

 

Cov qauv zoo ib yam thoob plaws txhua qhov kev kawm ywj pheej yog tib yam: dilute, deaerated, chav -kub HF ua rau cov nqi corrosion tsawg yog li lawv suav tias yog qhov tsis txaus ntseeg rau engineering lub hom phiaj, thaum aeration thiab siab kub tuaj yeem nce tus nqi li 10 mus rau 30 zaug hauv tib qhov concentration band.

Qhov kub thiab txias cuam tshuam li cas Monel 400's Corrosion Rate hauv HF?

Qhov kub thiab txias yog tib lub zog tsav ntawm corrosion. Cov nqi nyob qis thiab ruaj khov mus txog kwv yees li 90 degree, tom qab ntawd nce siab ntawm li 90℃thiab 120℃, thiab txuas ntxiv nce siab tshaj qhov ntawd - nrog lossis tsis muaj oxygen tam sim no.

 

Laboratory ua hauj lwm los ntawm Kane et al. (1993), tom qab rov tsim dua hauv Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) kawm ORNL/TM-2002/165, taug qab Monel 400 tus nqi corrosion hauv 49% HF los ntawm ambient kub txog li 150 degree. Hauv qab kwv yees li 88 degree, aerated thiab unaerated corrosion tus nqi tseem nyob ze ua ke thiab qis.

 

Thaum kub hla lub 88-120℃band, tus nqi corrosion nrawm nrawm hauv ob qho tib si aerated thiab unaerated tej yam kev mob - ib qho tsis tshua muaj qhov tsis suav nrog oxygen ib leeg tuaj yeem tswj tsis tau corrosion. Ntawm qhov siab hloov pauv kub ib yam ntawm kev lag luam HF ua haujlwm (ib puag ncig 200 degree), cov ntaub ntawv thiab cov ntaub ntawv tshuaj xyuas los ntawm Rebak li al. (2001) qhia Monel 400's vapor-theem corrosion tus nqi nce mus txog kwv yees li kaum npaug ntawm Hastelloy C-276 nyob rau hauv tib lub sijhawm.

 

Rau cov neeg tsim qauv cog, qhov ua tau zoo yog qhov ntsuas kub, tsis yog ib tus lej: hauv qab li 90 degree, zoo -deaerated Monel 400 cov cuab yeej tuaj yeem cia siab tias yuav muab lub neej ua haujlwm ntev ntev; saum toj no hais txog 120 degree, kev ntsuas kev tiv thaiv corrosion yuav tsum xav tias tus nqi siab dua, thiab lwm yam alloys yuav tsum raug soj ntsuam rau kev ua haujlwm siab ntxiv - kub.

Puas yog HF Kev Cuam Tshuam lossis Kub Kub Puas Muaj Qhov Zoo Tshaj Plaws rau Corrosion?

Kub thiab aeration (dissolved oxygen) dominate; concentration yog ib qho kev hloov pauv thib ob nyob rau feem ntau ntawm qhov ua tau zoo 0-70% HF ntau yam, txawm hais tias muaj ntau qhov sib xyaw ua ke nrog qhov kub thiab txias ua rau cov nyhuv.

 

Does HF Concentration or Temperature Have the Bigger Effect on Corrosion

 

Qhov no surprises ntau engineers siv rau acids xws li sulfuric los yog nitric, qhov twg concentration yog feem ntau tus thawj corrosion tsav tsheb. Rau Monel 400 hauv HF, luam tawm concentration-scan cov ntaub ntawv (piv txwv li, classic Nickel Institute immersion tests hla 0.05%, 1%, 10%, 24%, thiab 48% HF ntawm 24℃, 50℃, thiab 76℃) qhia tus nqi corrosion hloov ntau dua ntawm qhov kub thiab txias dua li ntawm qhov ntsuas kub. Stathopoulos et al. (2026) cov ntaub ntawv electrochemical txhawb qhov no: txav ntawm li 4% HF mus rau 40% HF ntawm tib 25℃tsuas yog hloov tus nqi corrosion ntawm 0.031 mus rau 0.04 mm / y - me me nce piv nrog 10–30 × dhia los ntawm aeration lossis 90℃+ kub nce.

 

This does not mean concentration is irrelevant. At a given elevated temperature, higher HF concentration still increases both the corrosion rate and the risk of stress corrosion cracking, and very high concentrations (>85-90% HF) txo cov dej ua haujlwm hauv txoj hauv kev uas tuaj yeem hloov cov txheej txheem corrosion dominates. Txoj cai tsim qauv siv tau yog los tswj qhov kub thiab txias ua ntej, tom qab ntawd txheeb xyuas qhov concentration- cov npoo tshwj xeeb rau cov txheej txheem kwj.

Vim li cas Aeration (Dissolved Oxygen) Ntau Tus Nqi Corrosion?

Cov pa oxygen thiab oxidizing cov kab mob (O2, Fe3+, Cu2+, los yog cov kua qaub sib xyaw xws li HF-HCl) strip tawm Monel 400's tiv thaiv fluoride zaj duab xis thiab tsav anodic dissolution txuas ntxiv, uas tuaj yeem nce tus nqi corrosion los ntawm 10-100 × piv nrog cov kua dej deaerated HF.

 

Hauv cov pa oxygen-dawb HF, Monel 400's npib tsib xee- tooj liab nto ua ib txheej nyias, adherent, ntau insoluble fluoride txheej uas ua raws li ib tug passive barrier, zoo xws li nyob rau hauv muaj nuj nqi (txawm hais tias tsis muaj pes tsawg leeg) rau cov chromium- oxide zaj duab xis uas tiv thaiv stainless hlau. Cov pa oxygen thiab oxidizing ions ua rau tsis muaj zog ntawm cov yeeb yaj kiab no los ntawm kev oxidation txuas ntxiv -txo kev caij tsheb kauj vab ntawm cov hlau nto, nthuav tawm cov hlau tshiab rau kev tawm tsam tshiab. 2026 Stathopoulos et al. txoj kev tshawb no ntsuas qhov kev sib koom ua ke ncaj qha: 1 M HF ib leeg muab tus nqi corrosion ntawm 0.031 mm / y, thiab 1 M HCl ib leeg muab 0.018 mm / y, tab sis qhov sib xyaw ua ke 1 M HF + 1 M HCl sib xyaw ua rau 0.051 mm / y - siab dua qhov sib npaug ntawm ob lub acids kuaj sib cais sib cais, sib cais. thaum muaj kab mob.

 

Tib txoj kev tshawb nrhiav pom tias vapor-theem raug cuam tshuam tsis tu ncua ntau dua li cov kua-theem raug ntawm tib lub npe nominal concentration thiab kub, vim tias ya raws ntawm cov hlau nyob hauv qhov chaw vapor yog txuas ntxiv nrog cov pa tshiab los ntawm cov pa ib puag ncig, thaum cov kua -phase acid nyob rau hauv lub nkoj kaw yooj yim dua nyob oxygen{3}de. Qhov no yog vim li cas HF cov kws tsim qauv cog lus hais tias tsis muaj zog- roj (nitrogen) pam vov thiab qhuav, oxygen- cov txheej txheem dawb raws li qhov tseem ceeb corrosion- tswj lub tswv yim rau Monel 400 cov cuab yeej, es tsis yog cia siab rau cov kev txwv siab ib leeg.

Monel 400 Puas Muaj Kev Nyuaj Siab Corrosion Cracking (SCC) hauv HF Service?

Yog lawm. Nyob rau hauv moist, aerated, dilute HF vapor (txog li 0.5% HF) ntawm qhov kub txog li 95 degree, Monel 400 tuaj yeem txhim kho kev nyuaj siab corrosion tawg, nrog cov kab nrib pleb hauv ob peb li 4-15 hnub hauv kev sim kuaj.

 

Qhov no yog hom kev ua tsis tiav los ntawm qhov dav dav - tsis muaj corrosion thiab tau sau tseg hauv ASM Phau Ntawv Qhia, Volume 13 (Corrosion), hais txog kev ua haujlwm hauv chav kuaj los ntawm Ciaraldi, Berry, thiab Johnson (1982). Lub tshuab, tau piav qhia hauv kev ua haujlwm dhau los los ntawm Copson thiab Cheng, suav nrog kev tsim cov khob tshuaj fluoride tso rau ntawm cov hlau hauv cov dej noo, oxidizing HF vapor; cov kev tso nyiaj no tsim cov xwm txheej hauv zos uas txhawb kev tawg txawm tias qhov dav dav corrosion nyob rau hauv tib qhov chaw yuav zoo li nruab nrab. Tshwj xeeb tshaj yog, K-Monel (UNS N05500), siab dua -lub zog, nag lossis daus- hardened variant, tsuas yog marginally resistant rau qhov no cracking dua standard Monel 400 - qhov sib tshooj ntawm ob alloys 'kav cwj pwm yog dav txaus uas alloy xaiv ib leeg yuav tsum tsis txhob cia siab rau SCC.

 

Kev ntsuas kev tswj hwm, rov ua dua thoob plaws txhua qhov kev tshuaj xyuas rau kab lus no, yog tib qho uas siv los tswj kev xeb dav dav: tsis suav nrog oxygen los ntawm qhov chaw vapor. Refinery HF alkylation units, piv txwv li, niaj hnub khaws cia nyob rau hauv tej yam kev mob uas txo cov huab cua ingress tshwj xeeb vim hais tias ob qho tag nrho corrosion thiab SCC ntawm Monel 400 nyob ntawm ntau yam ntawm oxygen muaj.

Monel 400 Piv rau Hastelloy C-276, Inconel 600, thiab 316 Stainless Hlau li cas hauv HF?

Hauv cov kua deearated HF ntawm qhov kub nruab nrab, Monel 400 yog tus nqi -zoo, zoo- pov thawj xaiv. Thaum qhov kub thiab txias, hauv aerated/oxidizing HF, los yog qhov yuav tsum tau siv lub neej ntev tshaj plaws, Hastelloy C-276 outperforms Monel 400 los ntawm ib tug dav margin. 316 stainless hlau yog unsuitable rau kua-theem HF kev pab cuam ntawm ib qho ntawm cov concentrations thiab kub tshuaj xyuas ntawm no.

 

Alloy

Nominal Composition

Kev coj tus cwj pwm hauv HF (raws li kev txheeb xyuas qhov chaw)

Cov txheeb ze Ranking

Monel 400 (N04400)

67% Ni - 31.5% Cu - 1.2% Fe

Zoo heev nyob rau hauv deaerated kua HF ntawm tag nrho cov concentrations rau boiling; corrosion accelerates sharply saum ~ 90-120℃los yog aeration; susceptible rau SCC nyob rau hauv moist, aerated, dilute vapor

Muaj zog dav dav - lub hom phiaj xaiv; saib kub thiab oxygen

Hastelloy C-276

57% Ni - 16% Cr - 16% Mo - 4% W

Kev ua tau zoo ntawm Monel 400 thiab Inconel 600 hauv txhua qhov kev sib piv kev tshuaj xyuas, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog nyob rau hauv qhov kub thiab txias thiab nyob rau hauv oxidizing / aerated tej yam kev mob (~ 10 × qis npaum li cas alloy 400 ntawm 200℃vapor)

Ua tau zoo tshaj plaws rau qhov hnyav lossis siab -kub HF kev pabcuam

Inconel 600

76% Ni - 15.5% Cr - 8% Fe

Nruab nrab kuj; nres concentrates ntawm cov kua / vapor interface; roughly 4 × zoo dua 316 SS hauv immersion tab sis zoo qab Hastelloy C-276 thiab Monel 400 nyob rau hauv feem ntau sib piv ncaj qha

Nruab nrab; feem ntau yog siv rau hauv tshuab raj / vapor- qhov chaw raug

316 Stainless hlau

12% Ni - 17% Cr - 2.5% Mo - tshuav Fe

Kev mob hnyav, nrawm nrawm hauv qab cov kua kab; corrosion tus nqi ntsuas ntawm 550–1,800 mpy (14–46 mm/y) hauv 33 wt% HF immersion kuaj

Tsis haum rau cov kua HF tiv tauj

Table 2. Sib pive HF corrosion kev ua tau zoo ntawm cov khoom siv siab- alloy, raws li ORNL/TM-2002/165, Rebak et al. (2001), thiab lwm yam ntaub ntawv.

 

Ib txoj hauv kev muaj txiaj ntsig kom nco qab qhov kev xav tau, siab - kub, lossis oxidizing HF kev pabcuam yog: Hastelloy C-276 > Inconel 600 > Monel 400 > 316 stainless hlau. Rau me me, deaerated, nruab nrab-kub kua HF - feem ntau ntawm kev cia, hloov mus, thiab qis-cov txheej txheem kev kub ntxhov - Monel 400 tseem yog kev lag luam- qauv, cov khoom siv tau zoo ntawm kev tsim kho.

Dab tsi yog Qhov Kev Ntsuas Kub thiab Kev Cuam Tshuam rau Monel 400 hauv HF Kev Pabcuam?

Monel 400 zoo haum rau qhov tseem ceeb ntawm HF concentration hauv cov kua dej deaerated mus txog rau qhov kub kub; Kev ceeb toom yog lav siab tshaj li 90 degree, nyob rau hauv moist aerated vapor, los yog nyob qhov twg oxidizing contaminants, thiab Hastelloy C-276 yuav tsum tau txiav txim siab saum toj no roughly 120℃los yog nyob rau hauv tas li oxidizing tej yam kev mob.

 

Monel 400 in HF Service

 

Kev Pabcuam

Kev taw qhia

Deearated kua HF, tej concentration, mus txog rau boiling point

Monel 400 zoo haum; cia siab tias tus nqi corrosion ntawm qhov kev txiav txim ntawm 0.025 mm / y (1 mpy) lossis qis dua ntev - kev pabcuam sijhawm.

Aerated kua lossis moist vapor, qis dua ~ 90 degree

Siv tau nrog ceev faj; corrosion tus nqi tuaj yeem nce mus rau 0.25–0.75 mm / y (10–30 mpy) ntau yam, thiab SCC kev pheej hmoo muaj nyob rau hauv dilute (tsawg dua lossis sib npaug li 0.5%) vapor - txo qis oxygen ingress thiab ya raws.

Txhua theem HF, 90-120 degree

Hloov chaw; corrosion tus nqi pib nce siab, kub-tsav nce txawm tias tsis muaj aeration. Rov ntsuam xyuas qhov kev tiv thaiv corrosion thiab tshuaj xyuas zaus.

Kev pabcuam txuas ntxiv saum toj no ~ 120 degree, lossis nrog O2/Fe3+/Cu{3}} raug

Corrosion tus nqi accelerates sharply; soj ntsuam Hastelloy C-276 lossis sib npaug Ni-Cr-Mo alloy rau cov khoom ua haujlwm tas mus li.

Mixed{0}}acid ntws (piv txwv li, HF + HCl condensates)

Cia siab tias synergistic acceleration tshaj li acid ib leeg; tsim rau qhov sib xyaw-acid corrosion tus nqi, tsis yog HF tus nqi hauv kev sib cais.

Table 3. Engineering kev taw qhia rau Monel 400 xaiv hauv HF kev pabcuam, muab los ntawm cov ntaub ntawv corrosion tshuaj xyuas hauv kab lus no. Cov duab no qhia txog cov ntaub ntawv xeem luam tawm thiab tsis yog qhov hloov pauv rau qhov project- tshwj xeeb kuaj corrosion.

 

Cov lus nug nquag

 

Monel 400 tus nqi corrosion hauv hydrofluoric acid yog dab tsi?

Hauv cov kua deearated HF ntawm qhov kub nruab nrab, Monel 400 feem ntau corrodes tsawg dua 0.025–0.04 mm / xyoo (kwv yees li 1–1.6 mpy). Hauv aerated 33 wt% HF ntawm ambient kub, luam tawm cov ntaub ntawv xeem qhia tau tias tus nqi nce mus txog 0.25–0.74 mm / xyoo (10–29 mpy) dhau ib- hli raug.

 

Monel 400 puas tuaj yeem siv hauv 49% hydrofluoric acid?

Yog lawm. Monel 400 yog siv dav hauv 49% HF cov kev pabcuam ua kua, suav nrog HF alkylation units, muab lub kaw lus khaws cia deaerated thiab kev khiav hauj lwm kub nyob rau hauv qis dua 90-120 degree. Tshaj li qhov ntau, corrosion nrawm nrawm tsis hais cov ntsiab lus oxygen.

 

Puas yog Monel 400 resistant rau hydrofluoric acid kev nyuaj siab corrosion tawg?

Tsis tag. Monel 400 tuaj yeem txhim kho kev ntxhov siab cuam tshuam kev tawg hauv cov av noo, aerated, dilute HF vapor (txog li 0.5% HF) ntawm qhov kub txog li 95 degree, nrog kev tawg qhia hauv chav kuaj hauv 4-15 hnub. Tsis suav nrog cov pa oxygen los ntawm qhov chaw vapor yog qhov kev ntsuas tseem ceeb.

 

Puas yog nce HF concentration ib txwm nce Monel 400 tus nqi corrosion?

Tsuas yog modestly ntawm nws tus kheej. Nyob rau hauv feem ntau ntawm cov tswv yim concentration ntau, kub thiab yaj oxygen hloov tus nqi corrosion ntau tshaj li qhov concentration. Concentration ua qhov tseem ceeb tsuas yog thaum ua ke nrog kub siab lossis oxidizing cov kab mob.

 

Yam khoom twg yuav tsum hloov Monel 400 rau siab -kub HF kev pabcuam?

Hastelloy C-276 yog tus qauv hloov tshiab. Cov ntaub ntawv cov ntaub ntawv qhia tias nws corroding ntawm kwv yees li ib feem kaum tus nqi ntawm Monel 400 nyob rau hauv HF vapor ntawm 200℃thiab tsis tu ncua outperforming Monel 400 nyob rau hauv aerated los yog oxidizing tej yam kev mob ntawm tej kub.

 

Xa kev nug
Los rau peb
Thiab pib koj rfqs tam sim no.
Tiv Tauj Peb